How to Build a Loyal Email Audience

In partnership with

Email marketing works. But most people do it wrong. They treat it like a numbers game instead of what it really is—building relationships with real people.

The best email marketers think long-term. They focus on trust over quick sales. They understand that someone might read their emails for months before buying anything. That's fine. The relationship matters more than the immediate sale.

Mistakes That Kill Your List

Sending Too Many Emails

This is the big one. You promise weekly emails, then send daily promotions. Your subscribers feel betrayed. They unsubscribe or ignore you.

Email sits in personal space. Next to messages from family and banks. Treat it that way.

Follow the 70/30 rule: 70% of your emails should build relationships and provide value. Only 30% should sell something. Your subscribers need time to breathe between pitches.

Treating Everyone the Same

Sending the same email to everyone is like shouting from a mountaintop. Someone might hear you, but you're too far away to connect.

Segment your list. Cat owners get cat content. Dog owners get dog content. New subscribers get different emails than long-time readers. This isn't complicated—it's basic respect for your audience.

Go beyond demographics. Understand what people care about, what they believe, what problems keep them awake at night. Then write to those specific concerns.

Technical Problems That Make You Look Amateurish

Half your emails get opened on phones. If yours don't work on mobile, you look sloppy.

Other problems: emails that bounce, designs that break, messages that land in spam folders. These technical issues kill credibility faster than bad writing.

Get the basics right. Clean your list regularly. Set up proper authentication. Monitor your sender reputation. Boring stuff, but essential.

We’ll get into long-term thinking after a word from…

🚨 Want to become famous(er), grab more customers, and 100X your reach?

Stop burning budget on ads and hoping for clicks. Podcast listeners lean in, hang on every word, and buy from guests who deliver real value. But appearing on dozens of incredible podcasts overnight as a guest has been impossible to all but the most famous.

PodPitch.com is the NEW software that books you as a guest (over and over!) on the exact kind of podcasts you want to appear on – automatically.

⚡ Drop your LinkedIn URL into PodPitch.
🤖 Scans 4 Million Podcasts: PodPitch.com's engine crawls every active show to surface your perfect podcast matches in seconds.
🔄 Listens to them For You: PodPitch literally listens to podcasts for you to think about how to best get the host's attention for your targets.
📈 Writes Emails, Sends, And Follows Up Until Booked: PodPitch.com writes hyper-personalized pitches, sends them from your email address, and will keep following up until you're booked.

👉 Want to go on 7+ podcasts every month? Book a demo now and we'll show you what podcasts YOU can guest on ASAP:

Book Your Incredible Demo Now

Building Real Relationships

Think Long-Term

The best approach is indefinite nurturing. You're not running a campaign with a clear end—you're building relationships that could last years.

This changes everything. Instead of obsessing over this week's click-through rate, focus on long-term engagement. Track how subscribers behave over months, not days. That person who opens every email but hasn't bought anything yet? They're incredibly valuable.

Stay Human in the Age of AI

AI can help with email marketing. But people want to know there are real humans behind the brands they follow. They can sense when content feels robotic.

Share real stories. Talk about your mistakes and what you learned. Show behind-the-scenes glimpses of your business. Feature actual customer stories. Make subscribers feel connected to people, not a corporate machine.

Be Transparent and Consistent

Tell people what to expect. How often will you email? What kind of content will you share? How will you use their information?

Then deliver on those promises. Every email should provide something worthwhile—education, entertainment, insight, or valuable offers. Subscribers should feel their time is respected.

Tactics That Actually Work

Build Your List the Right Way

Focus on quality over quantity. Better to have 100 engaged subscribers than 1,000 who ignore you.

Use opt-in forms strategically. But make subscription feel like a benefit, not a favor to you. Offer something valuable in return—a guide, template, discount, or exclusive access.

Your lead magnet should solve a real problem for your ideal audience. Generic incentives attract generic subscribers who won't engage long-term.

Create Content That Matters

Each email should focus on one thing. One topic, one idea, one problem, one solution. Multiple messages in one email confuse people.

Address common questions. Share personal experiences and lessons learned. Feature customer success stories. Provide industry insights people can't find elsewhere.

Tell stories. Especially personal ones. Talk about vulnerable situations, mistakes you've made, lessons you learned. This builds the human connection that turns subscribers into customers.

Automate Without Losing the Human Touch

You need systems that scale. But automation should never feel automated to the recipient.

Set up sequences for key moments: new subscriber welcome, post-purchase follow-up, abandoned cart recovery. But personalize beyond first names. Understand what people need at different stages of their relationship with your brand.

Create long-term nurture sequences that can run for months or years. Keep providing value to subscribers who aren't ready to buy yet. When they are ready, you'll be the first person they think of.

The Likability Factor

Sound Like a Real Person

Your tone matters. Professional for business communications, casual for internal team stuff, friendly for relationship building, empathetic when addressing problems.

Develop a consistent voice that reflects your personality. Use humor when appropriate. Share personal stories. Talk like someone your subscribers would enjoy having coffee with.

Avoid corporate jargon (AKA suit-talk). Nobody wants to read emails that sound like press releases.

Be Reliable

Likability often comes down to reliability. Maintain consistent email frequency. Provide value in every message. Be transparent about your intentions. Follow through on promises.

Subscribers should recognize your emails immediately and know what to expect when they open them. This predictability creates comfort and trust.

Respect subscriber preferences. Honor unsubscribe requests immediately. Maintain clear privacy policies. Don't overwhelm people with irrelevant offers.

Give Value First

The psychology of reciprocity is powerful. When you consistently provide value, people naturally develop positive feelings toward you.

Value doesn't always mean money. It can be education, entertainment, insights, or simply making people feel understood and appreciated.

Focus on solving problems, not just selling solutions. Acknowledge the challenges your audience faces. Position yourself as a trusted advisor, not another vendor trying to make a sale.

The Bottom Line

Building a loyal email audience isn't about tricks. It's about respecting the personal nature of email and using that privilege to create genuine value.

The marketers who succeed long-term understand they're not just sending messages—they're building relationships. This takes patience and authenticity, but it creates a foundation for lasting business success.

Focus on quality at every level. Attract genuinely interested subscribers. Provide substantial value in every email. Build authentic relationships rather than manipulating people into quick purchases.

This approach takes longer. But creates loyal customers who make repeat purchases and become enthusiastic advocates for your brand. That's worth more than any quick conversion tactic.

Email marketing works when you treat it like what it is—a conversation with real people who chose to let you into their inbox. Respect that choice, good things will happen.

Please share Inbox Hacking with a fellow marketing genius or business owner. I appreciate you reading and sharing. 

Shane McLendon - Copy Kingpin